• Climate
    • Climate Change
    • Extreme Weather
    • Mitigation
    • Natural Phenomena
  • Green Living
    • Buildings
    • Farming
    • Food and Drink
    • Holidays
    • Home & Garden
    • Natural Health
    • Personal Journey
    • Shopping
  • Resources
    • Finance
    • Water
      • Fresh Water
      • Oceans
    • Energy
    • Trees
    • Waste
      • Composting
      • Pollution
      • Recycling
      • Reduction
      • Repurpose
      • Reuse
  • Biodiversity
    • Air
    • Water
    • Land
  • Innovation
    • Creativity
    • Design
      • Green Building
    • Science
  • Community
    • Civil Society Work
    • Climate Express
    • Eco Communities
    • Faith communities
    • Gatherings
      • Awards
      • Conferences
      • Expo
    • Green Jobs
    • Vulnerable People
  • Responsibility
    • Calls to Action
    • Business
      • Corporate
      • SME’s
    • Governance
      • Cities & Towns
      • Governments
      • Policy Development
    • Individual
  • Training
    • Books
    • Courses
    • DVD’s & Films
    • Youth
      • Bursaries
      • Challenges
      • Competitions
      • Internships
      • Mentorships
      • Schools

The Green Times

Climate change is the most widespread & complex problem humanity has ever faced! There is no time to waste and we need to turn green talk into profound green action. This is the intention of the GREEN TIMES.

Philippi farmers challenge development decisions in court

October 14, 2019 Leave a Comment

A legal battle over the Philippi Horticultural Area (PHA), situated in the urban edge of Cape Town, starts this week.

On 15 and 16 October 2019, the PHA Food & Farming Campaign will be arguing for the preservation of a key piece of agricultural land in the City of Cape Town’s jurisdiction that is under threat from proposed developments.

The case on the roll in the Western Cape High Court challenges administrative decisions made by the Western Cape MEC for Local Development, Environmental Affairs and Development Planning, his Department and the City of Cape Town to rezone a part of the PHA for mixed-use development.

The PHA provides livelihoods to thousands and is also considered vital to replenish the Cape Flats Aquifer (which lies beneath it). This aquifer can supplement the City’s water supplies during times of drought.

This land, farmed for more than 130 years, produces up to a third or more of Cape Town’s leafy produce. Studies show 5 000 jobs are also directly created by the PHA, and 55 000 indirectly.

Nazeer Sonday, the convenor of the PHA Campaign, summarises the situation as follows:

“The PHA is precious. It is under threat and we need to protect this area.” Sonday is a small-scale organic vegetable farmer in the area. Every single acre has a purpose. Every time politicians say they care about the PHA, they also seem to want to pave over a portion of it. We are saying: enough is enough. This is why we are now turning to the court.”

The PHA Campaign and Sonday are the two applicants in this case. The 13 respondents include provincial ministers and departments, as well as the City of Cape Town.

This case is the first against five different developments which, when combined, would eliminate a third of the PHA’s remaining 3 000 hectares of urban farmland. The case against Oakland City Development Company (Pty) Ltd consists of a review of four development decisions and a request for a protection order for the whole of the PHA.

The PHA Campaign’s legal representatives will argue that the decisions taken regarding the proposed developments ignored several studies highlighting the benefits of the PHA. This includes studies highlighting its role in local food security; recharging the Cape Flats Aquifer; the maintenance of the urban edge; the PHA’s heritage value; and its land reform potential.

The case also considers the question of whose jurisdiction it is to make decisions about the PHA – whether it lies with the National Department of Agriculture and should the land be considered ‘agricultural’ under the Subdivision of Agricultural Land Act (SALA).

The PHA Campaign will argue that the City and the Province should have regarded their constitutional obligations of cooperative governance and respected the mandate of the National Department of Agriculture to ensure food security as well as protecting this “unique and irreplaceable” agricultural land. It also argues that South Africa has international obligations to ensure the realisation of the right to food.

The environmental impact assessment and processes that informed the development authorisations are according to the PHA Campaign insufficient, flawed and even non-compliant with the relevant legislation and regulations.

The PHA Campaign believes that the environmental impact assessment reports, for instance, failed to adequately investigate and assess environmental impacts related to the Cape Flats Aquifer, food security, climate change and land reform. The decision-makers have also not considered the cumulative impacts of the proposed developments on the area, the PHA Campaign believes.

Sonday summarises: “It is time we hold our politicians and decision-makers accountable for the impact of their decisions on our future. We believe all the relevant information was not considered by the decision-makers.”

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • More
  • Email
  • Print
  • Pinterest

Related stories

tgt_bottom_banner_border_two_frames

Leave a Reply or Follow Cancel reply

Welcome to SA\s green news portal

Events

  1. W12 Congress

    January 27, 2020 @ 8:00 am - January 31, 2020 @ 5:00 pm
  2. African Marine Waste Network Conference

    April 20, 2020 @ 8:00 am - April 24, 2020 @ 5:00 pm

View All Events

Facebook feed

17 hours ago
BREAKING: Eskom to implement stage 4 load shedding from 2pm

More fun from Eishkom.. 😑

The utility says the stage 4 rotational power cuts are expected to continue until 06:00 on Saturday.

View on facebook
17 hours ago
Trump opens protected Alaskan Arctic refuge to oil drillers

The Bureau of Land Management will offer leases to the 1.6m-acre coastal plain which is home to threatened polar bears

View on facebook
17 hours ago
How salmon can transform a landscape

Protecting salmon in coastal Canada could have benefits that extend beyond the water they swim in and can have profound impacts on the surrounding landscape.

View on facebook
1 day ago
Sign the Petition

Anyone asking what can be done about the imminent 5G rollout, here you go:

Stop 5G rollout in Cape Town, South Africa.. and while we're at it, the world.

View on facebook
« ‹ 1 of 3 › »
  •      ECO DIRECTORY
    • Accommodation
    • Animals
    • Building
    • Cleaning
    • Clothing
    • Cosmetics
    • Electronics
    • Energy
      • Saving
      • Solar
    • Financial Services
    • Food/Farming
    • Gardening
    • Government
    • Health
    • Office
    • Publications
    • Restaurants
    • Supermarkets
    • Training
    • Transport
    • Trees
    • Waste
      • Composting
      • Recycling
    • Water
    • Web Services
fair game
PETCO
Foster And Welsh
Plastics SA
Cape Pulpit Radio
2012-giving-thanks-for-environmental-wins
CONTRIBUTE HERE
Do you like what we do? Would you like to help keep this work afloat with a small monthly contribution? Join as a member and let's do it together.
nedbank-plays-pivotal-role-in-sas-first-green-bond
BECOME A SPONSOR
Doing good is good for business. We rely on corporate CSI and philanthropic support to drive sustainability mainstream, where it belongs.
  • ABOUT GREEN TIMES
    • Our Ethos
    • Our Intention
  • Support
    • Editorial
    • Sales
    • Contributions
  • Journalist Training
  • Feedback from Our Clients
  • Newsfeed Archive
JOIN OUR SOCIAL NETWORKS
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
JOIN OUR MONTHLY NEWSFEED
Like our work? Please help Subscribe-now

      · Copyright © 2011–2019 All rights reserved · GREEN TIMES +2721 855 0518 · Design & Admin - THE GREEN TIMES ·

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.